csichick_2: (lindsey)
csichick_2 ([personal profile] csichick_2) wrote in [community profile] tv_talk2013-10-31 07:40 pm

Elementary: Home Base



This is the place to discuss season 2 of Elementary.

Past posts:
Episode 1
Episode 2
Episode 3
Episode 4
Episode 5

All future episodes will be discussed in this post.
merryghoul: road (zoe and mark)

Re: EPISODE 2:24: The Grand Experiment (Season Finale)

[personal profile] merryghoul 2014-05-16 03:02 am (UTC)(link)
Let me see if I can put a buffer here to make sure I don't spoil the finale for those who haven't seen it...
merryghoul: pigeon near the london eye (london pigeon)

Re: EPISODE 2:24: The Grand Experiment (Season Finale)

[personal profile] merryghoul 2014-05-16 03:12 am (UTC)(link)
(If not, I can put a spoiler cut text thing here.)

Oh, wow.

Not as charming as last year's finale, but it was still great.

Loved the callbacks to things seen in ACD books and short stories. I think the Irregulars are now random people with webcams and webchat abilities? But I loved that they were represented in foiling the crooked MI6 agent.

Instead of Sherlock "falling," Mycroft was the one to "fall." I liked that twist.

Poor Joan. The whole MI6 thing destroyed her relationship with Mycroft. I feel bad for her, unlike some people that have been complaining about Joan/Mycroft for most of the season. She clearly wants a life outside of Sherlock and his (murder) mysteries, but Sherlock can't seem to handle life without her...for now. And even though some people didn't like the idea of Joan/Mycroft (but are fine with the show not sticking to ACD's books and short stories to the letter), Joan really thought Mycroft could make her happy, Sherlock or no Sherlock.

I don't like the open ending for this season, but since it already has a third season in the works, it's okay for now. Sherlock working with MI6 will certainly put a kink in his relationships with Joan and the NYPD.

Oh, and that library Mycroft was stashed in was gorgeous.